Jump to content
I Forge Iron

True prices for anvils.


Recommended Posts

last anvil I bought was about 140 lbs came into my shop wasnt looking for one so told the guy i could only afford to pay 100 dollars for it ...was unmarked and not to bad of shape sold it within a week for double my money to a guy who had his anvil stolen this was a couple of months ago.... anvil before that was a 100 lb anvil I bought at a aaba gettogether for 130. along with a swage block for 75.that was about 4 years ago...best deal my fisher 200 lb main anvil got it out of the budwizer hidroplane shop paid 100. for it ... that was about 20 years ago ...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 174
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

I've owned 9 or 10 anvils over the years but have only kept my first one, a 250 lb Peter Wright...and a 100 lb Hay Budden I bought for a portable rig. I traded an old Winchester that was worth about $125 at the time for the PW, which was around 1984. The Hay Budden was purchased about 1993 and I paid $140 for it. However, the PW needed a great deal of work to make it usable and the Hay Budden needed nothing so there was some disparity in initial condition.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

172# unknown havent found any markings(put it straight to use) edges are a bit beat up and has a bit of dish to it but for my first anvil 40$ and half an 30 miles worth of diesel from craigslist. I was thinkin about takin some navaljelly to the sides of it but im not sure.... Anvil # 2 comin soon from my step brothers basement, unknown size (other than 1 man can carry it) unknown condition, but the price is right if it ever gets here...

Anvil_stand_13.jpganvil_stand_41.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

~120# Peter Wright, $250.

Condition is not great, but more than good enough. I was pleased to be able to discern the brand as I bought it as an "antique" anvil. I assumed that I'd overpaid, being in a spendy part of the country, but it looks like I was in the ballpark.

As an aside, the guy I bought it from had something like ten clawfoot tubs in use as planters and 15-20 airstream trailers. Frankly, that alone would be worth a premium.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...

My first:
PW 177# : $250.00 very nice, beautiful long horn (still wish I had it)
The rest that I can remember:
PW 248# : $375.00 flat with no saddle, short horn though, sold it with the cut-off hardie
PW 125# : $225.00 about a 7/10
PW 148# : $90.00 very poor, wasn't worth the fuel to get it
Ajax 90# : $150.00 very nice, still have it
Trenton 150# : 275.00 very nice, ended up selling it for $300.00 (at least I got some of my fuel back out of this deal
Unkown london pattern solid wrought 112# : $75.00 - then some lady walked over and offered me $150.00 - it now sits painted bright blue in her flower garden (rather ignoble place for an anvil)
About ten or so more that I can recall. These days I haven't heard of anything going for less than $1.00/# for poor all the way up to $3.50/# for excellent condition
Refflinghaus 440# (new, see pic) : I won't tell, you may cry

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 3 weeks later...

Smith Steel Castings 70# Farrier - $120 in 2001
Russian Sub 110# $70 in 2001
167# Old World German Pattern -$340 in 2003
100# TFS Blacksmith Model $550 in 2008
All anvils were bought new except the Farrier which was not new but never used. I currently own only the Old World and the TFS anvils, both of which are excellent tools.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

A.S.O. 50lbs. (very first anvil over ten years ago) $50.00
Paragon 155lbs. $150.00
Unkown 500lbs. $295.00, $205.00 to ship (ouch)
Peter Wright 96lbs. $150.00
Peter Wright 156lbs. $250.00
English Coachmaker's 157lbs. $125.00
Hay budden 146lbs. $267.00
Wilkinson 166lbs. $40.00 (missing heel, long civil war story)
Unknown 30lbs. $20.00
Railroad anvil nicely made $free

Link to comment
Share on other sites

89 kg.- 1 3/4 CW- New- April 2008 $350- Finally a true story of the gem "Been in back room here through at least two long time former owners of this hardware store." City of Big Shoulders, Illinois- Endless thanks to a Madman Serb fellow toolmaker and monger in the woodworking trades.jet

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...

Peter Wright
95 lbs.
excellent condition

Bought it Fall 2000 for $400, price included a forge and Champion blower. Sold Fall 2004 for $150 due to divorce. Repurchased two days ago for $200 as the first step in rebuilding my forge and workshop! Whoo-hoo!

I guess anvils and bad pennies always come back....

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...

89 lb Peter Wright, $125.00, 2 yrs ago. 125 lb. farriers anvil, $125.00, 3 yrs ago. 150 lb Trenton, $350.00, last weekend. Farriers anvil like new, Trenton and PW good useable shape. All in the Pacific northwest.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


×
×
  • Create New...