Jump to content
I Forge Iron

Your LPG / Propane Questions answered


Corin

Recommended Posts

Hi People,

I have just joined this forum, and I am a newbie to blacksmithing having only a years experience.

I am not a Newbie to Propane. I have worked with Propane my whole life, I live and breath the stuff.
I am amazed by the miss information out there in blacksmith land, concerning this amazingly versatile and relatively safe energy source.

A little about me... I do not know everything about Propane, though I would like to . I do have access to one of the best libraries on the subject you will find anywhere in the world. If I don't know I will say so and probably direct you to somebody who will. If I say something you disagree with please say so, I am not perfect as I said, and it is important that all information shared is correct.

In my part of the world my trade is "Advanced LP Gasfitter", I do not work to American Standards such as NFPA 58, and whilst I own a copy I am not qualified to assist with your local legal requirements unless of course you are in NSW Australia. I am very familiar with all applicable codes in Australia, but not necessarily local enforcement and requirements.

I have repaired and helped with burner design on countless forges, but I am no expert in Burner design. I can trouble shoot, calculate your burners capacity, and assist in other areas. My own forge from cold start up takes about 2 1/2 minutes to melt 1/2" steel bar. I am pretty pleased with it. It is naturally inspirated (ie no blower).

If you have a question about propane, try me.


Lets give this a go, hopefully I will be able to assist.

Please note that I give my answers in good faith, as I believe through better understanding comes increased safety. In any matter involving Propane you should consult your local qualified tradespeople to ensure what you are doing, is both safe and complies with local legal requirements. All care taken no responsibility.

Link to comment
Share on other sites


How can you melt steel with propane? I thought it doesn't get that hot. I have been using gas forges for 15 years.


Hi Mate,

Great question to kick off!

The maximum flame temperature for combustion for Propane is 3595°F This is in ideal conditions with oxygen. If you are burning air, as I do you are introducing Nitrogen (about 70% which is heated in the reaction and naturally cools the flame temperature. even with a super efficient burner you will not get this kind of temperature, but don't let that stop you. Almost as importantly you need to introduce and retain as much heat as possible within the forge. Steel melts at around 2500°F, it is not as hard as you think.

You need to consider two things.... Temperature, and Heat They are distinctly different animals. Think about it this way... a candle flame and a campfire flame will have approximately the same flame temperature, but a campfire will boil a large pot of water, where a candle will never get it up to temperature, as heat is lost from the pot as fast as you put it in. Your flame in your forge may have the temperature (try melting a piece of fine steel wire) but you may not have (or be able to retain) enough heat to melt anything bigger.

Their most certainly are home built forges out there normally with blowers, that get hot enough to smelt steel/iron.

This is a bad example, but it does show it is not that hard.

backyard foundry

Mine is different in as much as it uses a venturi and high gas pressure as opposed to a blower. Same principal.

I should add... these temperature destroy ceramic fiber wool, and molten steel destroys the floor of your forge... it is still fun though :D
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi Corin
Mat from hot sunny and drying-out Brisbane. My question re- propane is many appliances have a small screw to disrupt the flow of propane and air, improving the mix. Would an atmospheric burner benefit from this or do the higher PSI's involved make this redundant?
Thank you.

Link to comment
Share on other sites


How can you melt steel with propane? I thought it doesn't get that hot. I have been using gas forges for 15 years.


I can attest that propane will absolutely get hot enough to melt steel. Albeit, my forge has a forced air burner, if you put enough BTUs in a small enough space you can melt refractory if it isn't rated high enough DAMHIK ;) BTW, Welcome Corin :)
Scott
Link to comment
Share on other sites


Hi Corin
Mat from hot sunny and drying-out Brisbane. My question re- propane is many appliances have a small screw to disrupt the flow of propane and air, improving the mix. Would an atmospheric burner benefit from this or do the higher PSI's involved make this redundant?
Thank you.




Mate I feel for you guys... Our Queensland office is in Milton. I spent a few days up there helping mop up, what a mess. Here is a picture for those that don't know where Milton is... our office is in the black circle.

Untitled2.jpg


Now to Answer your question.... the screw you are referring to is a low cost easy method for low pressure burners normally found on BBQ burners and the like... for high pressure burners, lacking burner ports, like those we use for forges I would not think they would be ideal. I would be using a shutter that evenly blocks the air from all sides equally, thus allowing a constant flame shape... You will see in my forge pictures below what I use.




Hello Corin, welcome. Any chance of some pictures of your forge?


Sure! Here are some of the pics I took during its first relining after only 6 months the refractory was falling apart from too much heat too often, as you will see the floor was stuffed too from molten stuff... :D


First, Here is the whole forge, note I have changed the gas inlet since this picture was taken, note also the door reducer in place I will explain these later... It is made from an old 20# (9kg) cylinder.

Please don't just cut into any old propane tank... it may well erase your genes from the pool so to speak, which if you are that stupid is a good thing for the rest of us... get one that has been de-valved internally cleaned from your local gas merchant. It may cost you a few dollars, but not your life.

P8020037.jpg

Next is a picture of the forge after a few months of abuse.. lol no regrets,

P9051921.jpg

Next are a series of pictures of the rebuild they should be self explanatory. If you have questions please ask.

P9051926.jpg
P9051927.jpg
P9051928.jpg
P9051929.jpg
P9051930.jpg
P9051931.jpg
P9051931.jpg
P9051932.jpg
P9051933.jpg
P9051935.jpg
P9051936.jpg
P9051937.jpg
P9051941.jpg

Ok I will stop there and see if this forum will handle so many pics....Sorry no idea yet,
Link to comment
Share on other sites


I can attest that propane will absolutely get hot enough to melt steel. Albeit, my forge has a forced air burner, if you put enough BTUs in a small enough space you can melt refractory if it isn't rated high enough DAMHIK ;) BTW, Welcome Corin :)
Scott


Thanks for the Welcome, and everyone else who said that too for that matter.

LOL I have to either stop getting it so hot for the fun of it or find better refractory. I scored all my refractory for the pricely some of some help with a kiln burner, so until I run out care factor is zero....




My problem is usually I no time to experiment with these things. I have just a pile of steel that needs to be forged into something and a stack of bills that need to be payed.


I guess I am lucky... for a long time I have been paid to do it.... I do so love my job.




Corin: Your post mainly said that you were here to answer questions.......Sooooooo: How about some info on your atmospheric burner... Orifice size and mixing chamber design. Thanks so much... Eric Sprado



Ok... for my forge... with my exact setup the orifice size is a number 65 Drill. It was smaller before the rebuild, but worked differently after so I re-tuned it.

for the burner there are four key components,
Lets start with the venturi, it is the one that seams to be least understood, and really to the detriment of most forges. My advice is don't stuff around, buy a short pattern inspirator, they look so simple but if you don't get it right you are just wasting your time. a good venturi gives you a similar effect to a blower, but uses the energy of the gas entering at high velocity (pressure) to draw the air in. P1260360.jpg

You can adjust the air as follows from closed to maximumand anywhere in between ;
P1260363.jpg
P1260364.jpg
P1260365.jpg
P1260366.jpg

Lots of flexibility is what you want with air adjustment, If you cab adjust your pressure and hence your gas flow and velocity, and you can adjust your air you will have a very versatile burner.

Next lets talk about the jet. With this type of burner you need to use high pressure to get the super high temps, as I say above you need gas velocity and a good venturi to pull in the air.

Small jet, high pressure, will give better results than a large jet and low pressure despite the effective heat output being equal.

I modified my jet and it works heaps better... more on that another day. The jet size needs to be tuned to your burner and your forge, start small and work up. Use number drills and go up one at a time until you are happy.

Burner tube is just a bit of scrap 1" shedule 80 tube threaded at both ends. I tried a few different lengths. 12" was absolutely the best.

Next is the flame retention nozzle. This is the bit that seams to be a hot topic... I will simplify it for you. You need to step up from whatever your burner tube is to a bit bigger for a short length... pretty much anything that does that should work effectively in a forge.

I use a 3000LB steel 1" 1 1/2" steel reducing coupling. cheap, heavy duty and effective.
P1260357.jpg
P1260356.jpg


Too easy!




My forced air can melt steel



That thing is pretty cool... errr I mean Hot.... err I mean it looks good ;)
Link to comment
Share on other sites


thanks,keep it coming.can you give more in fo on your burner dimentions ect thanks again



Sorry if I was not clear enough... 1" BSP short pattern inspirator, 1" (id) Schedule 80 tube 12" long threaded both ends (1" BSP) then a 1" to 1 1/2" 3000 LB reducing coupling... Thats pretty much it.

The part numbers for these items at Gameco in Milton
are
1" Insporator/venturi NGB-1
Reducing coupling PCP4025
Pipe... made to order in gameco NSW... by me funnily enough...
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Corin, welcome to IFI, and thanks for the great information! One question regarding higher temps. You mentioned "high gas pressures". How high is high? I usually run around 8 psi for normal forging, and don't feel I get enough heat for effective welding, but have been reluctant to crank up the pressure too high. My forge is very similiar to yours, single burner, shell made from 20# tank, 2 inches of dura-blanket plus reflective coating (ITC100).
Also, on a different note, there has been a lot of interest in ribbon burners as of late. Can you comment on any experience you have had with those? Very interesting thread!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Welcome to Iforge!

I'm currently running a blown forge (also made from a 20lb propane tank) and considering making an aspirated forge to get unplugged. I'm currently getting a bit more than 5h from a 20lb tank of propane.

Seeing as you have the same size forge, how long can you get out of a tank?

Cheers,
T.

Link to comment
Share on other sites


How can you melt steel with propane? I thought it doesn't get that hot. I have been using gas forges for 15 years.



Good insulation,good pressure with the blower and enough propane to burn.....how much is enough depends on the forge size and what is in the forge.

Ric
Link to comment
Share on other sites

When I relined one of my propane forges I doubled the kaowool thickness and soon learned that if I didn't ease it back it would cheerfully melt my steel at the same burner adjustments that would just get it hot for forging prior to the re-line. 2 factors: reduced volume and reduced heat loss.

Link to comment
Share on other sites


One question regarding higher temps. You mentioned "high gas pressures". How high is high? I usually run around 8 psi for normal forging, and don't feel I get enough heat for effective welding, but have been reluctant to crank up the pressure too high. My forge is very similiar to yours, single burner, shell made from 20# tank, 2 inches of dura-blanket plus reflective coating (ITC100).
Also, on a different note, there has been a lot of interest in ribbon burners as of late. Can you comment on any experience you have had with those? Very interesting thread!!


Hi Mate,

I want to be really specific here, my experience is in repairing, servicing, trouble shooting, adjusting, and using gas burners. Not in designing them. I tried no less than 6 different burners in my forge (Because I could mainly) and quite a few different configurations also. I did not arrive at my burner through guess work or science, but testing, trial and error.

Great question, With my venturi and burner set up, things get excitingly hot at around 50-60 PSI. With a door reducer in place, you can get to welding heat at about 30 PSI, probably less but it take longer.

To give some science on this subject, With the same sized jet... Lets say a #65 Drill The difference in energy input is approximately double if the pressure is raised from 10 PSI to 50 PSI

To give you a really good answer to this question, find out some answers to as many of the following questions as possible, and I will run some comparative energy calculations and see where the differences lie, and maybe even a few things for you to try.

Can your regulator go higher?
What is the lowest ambient temperature in your area or shop?
What size cylinders are you using?
Do all of your components have a rated working pressure suitable for higher pressures?
What size Jet are you using?
Do you have good adjustment of primary air on your venturi?
Do you have a good well designed venturi? My link
What local requirements are in place regarding the pressures and approvals to home built appliances?


Regarding part 2 of your question I am very interested, do you have a link? I would love to take a look.


I'm currently running a blown forge (also made from a 20lb propane tank) and considering making an aspirated forge to get unplugged. I'm currently getting a bit more than 5h from a 20lb tank of propane.

Seeing as you have the same size forge, how long can you get out of a tank?



Another great question.
To start with, if I give two different drivers the same car, and tell them to drive until the tank is empty and see how far they get, one will always do better than the other. for example one may be a lead foot and drive around town taking off from every set of lights at top speed, the other may get on the freeway and cruise at a moderate speed.
My point is even if we had exactly the same forge our usage patterns will be different.

I have a main flame/pilot flame bi-pass system on my forge, when I walk away from it I knock a ball valve with my knee, and it drops back to a low capacity holding flame.

I also never run my tanks (2 manifolded) empty, at low capacity wetted surface area is also reduced and hence vaporisation capacity. In simple terms you are taking out more gas than the liquid can boil off. I am sure someone will ask about this at some point and I will give a better explanation then.

In short I don't have the actual usage data to give you.

There is still a good answer to your question. There is data available for gas consumptions through orifices at different inlet pressures. Lets take a closer look at my forge.

There are a lot of variables that will effect how much heat is retained in the forge. but these figures are straight out of combustion engineering sizing tables.

I have a #65 orifice, and operate between 10 and 50 PSI

At 10 PSI I am using 2 pounds per hour.
At 20 PSI I am using 2.8 pounds per hour
At 30 PSI I am using 3.4 pounds per hour
At 40 PSI I am Using 4 pounds per hour
At 50 PSI I am using 4.4 pounds per hour

I normally work around the 20-30 PSI mark for general forging. So if I was using one 20 pound cylinder around 6-7 hours... There is no way a 9kg at low capacity can vapourize this kind of quantity for sustained periods, 2 works better but really you want bigger cylinders and more. I don't forge for hours on end, and keep them topped up. That works for me.


Good insulation,good pressure with the blower and enough propane to burn.....how much is enough depends on the forge size and what is in the forge.

Ric


Your on the money there mate. I will check the video out a bit later...


When I relined one of my propane forges I doubled the kaowool thickness and soon learned that if I didn't ease it back it would cheerfully melt my steel at the same burner adjustments that would just get it hot for forging prior to the re-line. 2 factors: reduced volume and reduced heat loss.


That is a really good point well made mate, and what I was trying to get at earlier. Most good pottery kilns I work with get to 2370 F with smaller burners and having huge internal volumes. The difference is they don't have big holes in the side, and normally are insulated with 6" of wool. If I was going for efficiency I would have a look at kiln design...
Link to comment
Share on other sites

sorry If I slip back into metric and other units during these posts, I am trying to keep to BTU Pounds, Feet, etc, but I work with all units of measure... and I do slip up occasionally. Happy to assist with conversions if you need 'em

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thats a great question, and one probably better put to a combustion engineer! It is out of my league, however I can make the following points.

I am working off combustion engineering orifice sizing and capacity tables for propane. These do not go higher than 50 PSI, and have been in use and accepted virtually unchanged for 50 years. I am going to assume it may be close to the wire, but is not a significant issue.

In the industry I am only aware of supersonic flows and choked flows causing issues in relief valve applications, where inappropriate sizing and inappropriate pipe-away pipework can significantly reduce a relief valves capacity and lead to container failure. A little more exciting than my forge melting steel I have to tell you. We do make allowances for supersonic flows when designing relief valve systems. I do not fully understand the subject though to be honest. As I said, out of my league at the moment.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Sonic flow occurs when the downstream pressure is approximately half of the upstream pressure. It's not quite that simple, but close enough. The downstream pressure for us is atmospheric or at sea level about 15 psi absolute (zero gauge).After that occurs, the flow rate is only dependent on the upstream pressure. 15 psi gauge pressure (30 psi absolute) would give half the flowrate as 45 psi gauge (60 psi absolute. This is roughly in line with the rates given. If you'd like more precise numbers, I can supply them. But roughly above 15 psi gauge you will have sonic flows in the orifice.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This is very interesting to me. I must say I still don't understand, though believe me I am trying. A quick web search to try to learn exactly what sonic flow is, why it occurs and the specific effect on flows when it occurs is not revealing anything that clears it up, in fact much information appears to be contradicting.

I then go back to combustion tables and measured flow through orifices in tabular form. I am looking for a change in the graphical curve around 15 PSI which there does not appear to be.

Many many years ago I myself spent considerable time developing a mathematical formula for calculating flows through orifices based on available tables (themselves based on measured flows through measurement using displacement meters and orifice plates), I cannot write formulas in forum format so I will write it in Excel format. I am no mathematician and it is possible this could be simplified further but what is certain is that it corresponds within approximately 5-10% with tabulated data on flows through orifices

F=SQRT(P)*POWER(D/2,2)*C

Where F = FLOW IN mj/h
P = Pressure in kPa
D = orifice diameter in mm
C = is Corins ;) Constant 28.26

Sorry it is in metric but I can supply conversions if required, I mostly work in metric.

No compensation is made for sonic flows from above 15 psi and yet this formula retains a high level of accuracy at those pressures. It is not perfect but there are many factors that influence flows through orifices and for working calculations for equipment sizing it has got me out of the proverbial on a number of occasions.

Where can I learn more about the effects of sonic flows, are there any reference books of web pages you can recommend?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Corin,
Curious about what pressure you're using - upstream absolute, upstream gauge or differential which in most cases would be upstream gauge. Beyond that You'll have to wait a few days and I'll get a better answer. It's currently near minus 30 degrees Celsius here. I have 34 horses to care for then head for the University to teach a class. You might search on critical flow provers, but think of sound as a pressure wave. The speed of sound in any medium is the speed that a pressure wave travels. Once that velocity is reached by the gas stream a change of pressure at one end of the orifice will not be transmitted to the other end, so the mass of gas flowing only depends on the max density of the gas or upon the upstream pressure. The downstream pressure or differential pressure drops out of the equation.

My guess with LPG is that your tables assume atmospheric as the low pressure. Then "pressure" is upstream gauge pressure or differential pressure. At subsonic flow the differential pressure is what counts. At high pressures there isn't too much difference between gauge and absolute and you've come up with an emperical equation that does good job of bridging the gap. If you're curious, My job deals with natural gas at very high pressures.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...