Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

I Forge Iron

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Any recopies for 5000 degree refractory in steel making?

Featured Replies

Just wondering.
I have quite a few that can stand that heat, but not many that can take molten iron/steel, and that won't impart gunk into the molten metal.

Also, if you know how to bond MgO, please speak up. Thanks, Jerry

5000 F?

what alloy are you melting that high?
Most steel will melt at 2500F (1370C)

these guys have everything
Refractories-west, Inc.
they are the former AP Green Pueblo Refractory Plant purchased by the employees when it was slated for closure
(there is quite a lot of history there the initial plant being brought online in 1890)

  • Author
5000 F?

what alloy are you melting that high?
Most steel will melt at 2500F (1370C)....



Um, well..
First, thanks for that awesome link. I really can use that. The MgO bricks are great! *kid in candy store*
As far as the temp requirements, well thats sort of my plane, so to speak. BTW, "Ice Czar" . Now that's ironic. :D;)
Thanks again Ice, for the resource! Jerry

ex operations manager in charge of ice for the Great American Beer Festival (13 years) been my online nic since I started :rolleyes:

not too strange since Im a thermodynamics geek, happy to help ;)

hmmm... 5000F, browns gas?
tungsten takes 6170F :p

  • Author

Well then.
Thermodynamics eh?
Ice and fire. Nice.
here is an mpg of my early steel making. A 10 pound charge of thermite..
It was too wide, and thus made a too large of a thermal mass. Melted clean through my 5000 furnace lining.

I have since learned how to tame the dragon. but try not to get cocky.
MOV01705.flv - Video - Photobucket - Video and Image Hosting
BTW, 6170 ain't no thang.. Back atcha

not to mention all the practice your getting if you forget the combination to your safe :P

you get an A+ for safety gear ;)

  • Author

Distance is the best safety gear:D
EDIT: Around 5% of my runs, that is iron, gets boiled off.

High Carbon Steel Melts at Approximately 2600F and low carbon steel melts at 2800F Often cast steel is poured at a few hundred degrees hotter for adequate fluidity. This is why high carbon steel burns easier when forging than lower carbon steels.

I suggest going out on the web to learn of available refractories.

  • Author
what are you casting? or are you?

Low alloy refractory steel. Stuff that does not exists in the text books....yet

Ive been able to alloy a rhenium alloy, and other transition metals, with other refractory elements, via exothermic reaction.
I'm being coy because I have patent pending.
EDIT: R Funk, ther is no carbon in this steel. It makes for a higher playground..

I'm being coy because I have patent pending.


one of the ten most expensive metals on earth known for its superconducting properties in some alloys patent pending? :P
a good refractory steel would be very useful around here

was actually looking for "wheel" "gear" "ingot" :P

have fun ;)

(its about time we had more alchemy in here)
  • Author

Boy, you ain't kidding.
Briefly, I chose rhenium because of it's unique properties. It's the only metal that is malleable from absolute zero, to it's melting point, which is quite high. Around 5200F!
The platinum group, can contribute to simple steel, above and beyond current paradigms.
Just like anything, all it takes is money...:mad:

J Bennet

Best of luck on your patent!

Let us know when you get it and can discuss it.

Patents can be a very interesting process. Are you going to go for several international patents or will you stick with US only?

Hi Jerry. If you are interested in thermite, you may wish to read:

http://journalof911studies.com/volume/200704/JLobdillThermiteChemistryWTC.pdf

Especially interesting is Figure 3. Disregard all the non-thermodynamic stuff. The appendix is a great reference section for the temperature dependent heat capacities of the reactants. The iron phase transitions are neglected, and these will cause the calculations to be optimistic (pessimistic :D:o). But the error introduced by neglecting radiation and other mechanisms of heat loss is much higher.

I wonder that, with sufficient diluent in the form of low carbon steel/iron, you could decrease the temperature requirement of the refractory. The characteristic heat transfer time for small steel punchings or granules is probably on the order of a second, with the high radiative component.

  • Author

That has a lot of useful information.
T-mite is low tech, but after observing scores of runs, some up to 12 pounds, I know that there are a lot of complicated thermal dynamics going on.

I didn't like the sulfur/iron info though. I assumed the reaction got rid of all that nasty stuff.
As for the 5000 degree requirement, I put melt doors in the bottom and a very small tap hole. That way it gives the reaction some time to settle and separate. Consequently it sits on the refractory a while. I've weighed the iron afterwards, including all the "spatter" I could find. I find that during large runs, about 5% of the iron boils away. There is probably +- 2% as there might be a bit of unreacted iron oxide in the slag. That's around 6000F. So there are "hot spots" in the reaction.

I have designed a t-mite furnace I call "the star chamber", that utilizes a lot of insulation and a large outside heat source. Heat on more heat. I imagine the "flame" in the middle of the reaction is approaching low fusion temps. I guess around 8 grand F. I'll have to set up a cheap spectro to see one day.

I have found MgO works the best as far as heat resistance, liquid resistance and cleanness. But it's very hard to bind into a usable ceramic form.
I was wondering if anyone had any other suggestions. Thanks for the link.

I know that there are a lot of complicated thermal dynamics going on.


nominated for an honorary doctorate of understatement :P

this may be of some interest
http://www.pat2pdf.org/patents/pat5152830.pdf (direct download)
thermite process for producing a metal or alloy (92)

a new thermite process with which the heat generated in the thermite reaction can be regulated by appropriately using cooling and exothermic agents at rates that can be controlled at each stage of the metallurgical reaction so that a high quality metal or alloy may be produced at a high yeild


In their first example they are employing quicklime (Calcium Oxide direct download again) as a fluxslag forming material and sodium chlorate as the exothermic agent (oxidizing agent commonly employed in oxygen candles)


Id check all the chemical reactions of course but a layered charging system might be just the ticket ;)

Good luck

ps attempting to order sodium chlorate would likely attract attention ;)

Jerry, while reading "Steelmaking Before Bessemer" vol II Crucible Steel, there was a reference to making Magnesia blocks by mixing it with something and heating. I'll try to dig up the exact reference for you this weekend.

  • Author
Id check all the chemical reactions of course but a layered charging system might be just the ticket

Good luck

ps attempting to order sodium chlorate would likely attract attention




Thanks. I ran across that while doing a patent search for my furnace:D

I've fooled around a little with the layered system, but it wasn't too complicated. It's good for adding carbon to make a certain alloy. My furnace is more mechanical, as it utilizes "drop mixing" and the slag is used as a "lid".

Jerry, while reading "Steelmaking Before Bessemer" vol II Crucible Steel, there was a reference to making Magnesia blocks by mixing it with something and heating. I'll try to dig up the exact reference for you this weekend.


That would be awsome. Adell's listed the old timey stuff as "magnesia tar". Have no idea what it was, but it must have been some sort of carbon binder.:confused:
  • Author

Thanks!
I'll be printing that out for my library:)
Wish I would have found this forum earlier.

J. Bennett
What ever you do, DO NOT go to IForgeIron.com > Lessons in Metalworking > Blacksmithing > LB0008 Reference material or LB0008.0001 Reference Material. There are over 100 on line blacksmithing and metalworking books behind those two links. More books and links are added as they become available, and the list keeps growing.

After catching up on your reading (grin), if you have questions, just ask.

  • Author

Wow.
Thanks to all the people who put the hard work into that.:) Great resource.

Something I dont understand, (theres alot of em..) is why cant we use a metal with a higher melting point to smelt the other one in? Like smelting bronze in a steel crucible.. would it contaminate the metals produced?

Oh, and where in oregon are you located? I'm in the corvallis/philomath area..

  • Author

That's a good question, but a very complicated answer. keep in mind I'm a backyard metallurgist, so take everything I say with a grain..
In alloy making, melting points are only for reference. You can alloy such and such a metal, say with a 4000F melting point, into molten iron @ 3300F. Why? It's called, well I actually don't know what it's called, but I call it the flux effect.

Just like molten flux can destroy a forge lining, several hundred degrees below it's melting point.

I would never use any metal crucibles to hold any other molten metals..
Although you can drastically reduce the melting point of alumina, and hold the liquid in a platinum crucible. Alumina, aluminum oxide, has a higher melting point than platinum, but the flux changes that. The making of Ramaura Cultured Rubies

I live in rural St. Paul, next to Champoeg.

ha, ya.. I dont get it :( you're definately leagues ahead of my understanding of metallurgy..
good luck on your experimentations!
and you're the same person from D-foggs site right? with the star chamber forge..
nice seeing you here!

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.