Ryan, before you do anything else, could you please do us a favor? POST SOME PICTURES.
I'm serious about this. To be blunt, your descriptions of what you are doing are very hard to understand. If you post some pictures, the people here (who WANT to help you!) will be able to look at what you have done and make suggestions on what you can do better.
If you really want our help, HELP US HELP YOU.
That said, I have to repeat what was said above about the JABOD. It's a proven design, and if it wasn't working, it's because either (A) you did something you shouldn't have, or (B) you didn't do something you should have. Once again, pictures would help.