Jump to content
I Forge Iron

can i make a knife out of brass


darton

Recommended Posts

Brass and bronze are pretty muddled now. If it is actually a bronze, yes, as there were bronze knives, and swords made during the bronze age. Won't hold an edge like a steel knife. Now, I have access to some beryllium copper, and that will get pretty hard when heat treated. BeCU is used for all manner of tools where non sparking is required IE; around explosive atmospheres.

Depending on the size, and shape, a lot of knife parts like guards could be made from it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hello:

Actually you CAN make a knife out of brass but you will need to cold work it and even then, it will not get very hard but it will be sharp enough to cut for a little while. You really need to know what you are doing cold working or else you can crack the material if you aren't paying attention.

The first metal implements were copper then various bronzes then iron and then steel..now they are going back to "rocks" (with the ceramics) but you can make a knife out of brass but why? Novetly? Just because? If so..go for it...Have fun doing it...it will be different but don not expect a decent edge that will last...

JPH

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Note that grinding BeCu, beryllium copper, can result in your death.

If you want to make non-ferrous "damascus" look into Mokume which can even be done just using US sandwich quarters...

A.G.Russel once flattened an Al beer can and honed it till it would shave. Didn't hold the edge long but it was sharp!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

We machine 1,000's of pounds of BeCU a year. The Be is an inhalation hazard, so grinding, or other processes that produce dust need proper respiratory protection. Same would go for casting. What we do in the way of machining produces chips which are not considered a health hazard. If worked properly, any number of items can be made from it. To just say leave it alone is not really the right answer in my opinion. I would say before using it make sure that you have educated yourself fully on all hazards, and safety equipment needed. We use items every day that are hazardous, and some choose to willingly subject themselves to hazardous items like cigarettes in spite of the warnings. We fill our cars with gasoline, use propane grills, coal forges, natural gas appliances, all manner of chemicals, and other potentially very hazardous, or deadly items everyday. With proper PSE, and education we can, and do all of these things safely. We let children fill up a car, and don't give it a second thought. It would scare the crap out of a lot of folks if they ever read the MSDS on many common items. Some people are still killed because they mixed ammonia, and bleach. Brake fluid, and bleach will ignite when mixed. All of these are common household items, yet when used improperly can result in injuries, or death.

Education keeps us alive, and healthy.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

We machine 1,000's of pounds of BeCU a year. The Be is an inhalation hazard, so grinding, or other processes that produce dust need proper respiratory protection. Same would go for casting. What we do in the way of machining produces chips which are not considered a health hazard. If worked properly, any number of items can be made from it. To just say leave it alone is not really the right answer in my opinion. I would say before using it make sure that you have educated yourself fully on all hazards, and safety equipment needed. We use items every day that are hazardous, and some choose to willingly subject themselves to hazardous items like cigarettes in spite of the warnings. We fill our cars with gasoline, use propane grills, coal forges, natural gas appliances, all manner of chemicals, and other potentially very hazardous, or deadly items everyday. With proper PSE, and education we can, and do all of these things safely. We let children fill up a car, and don't give it a second thought. It would scare the crap out of a lot of folks if they ever read the MSDS on many common items. Some people are still killed because they mixed ammonia, and bleach. Brake fluid, and bleach will ignite when mixed. All of these are common household items, yet when used improperly can result in injuries, or death.

Education keeps us alive, and healthy.



I agree....

but rather than that I am just curious what you guys make out of BeCU? I have seen many tools and once a huge roots style blower made out of the stuff... Just curious
Link to comment
Share on other sites

The company I work for makes high end electrical connectors , along with other high precision parts. When the company was in Vegas we were the largest Tornos Deco screwmachine shop in N. America with 60+ machines. It is now located in La Verkin UT. The company has made parts that are on the international space station, as well as the space shuttle. We also do fiber optic terminations, and recently did some that go on the F22 Raptor. We never know the final use of the vast majority of the parts we make. We just make parts for other people. We can turn up to 1" in diameter, but some stock we use is as small as .062". We make some parts with hole tolerances of .0002" that have to be held over tens of thousands of parts. The materials that we use mainly are copper, BeCU, brass, stainless, and some aluminum. Our bar ends would make nice material for rivets etc, they usually run around 7" long, and come in a variety of diameters of the various materials we use. I am the tool maker for the company.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You already have the main piece of equipment if you have a forge. For small amounts of brass the only other thing you would need is a crucible, and that can be just a large black iron pipe nipple with a cap. I'm sure that's how blacksmiths did small brass parts in years gone by, your forge will definately get to those temps easily. As far as a mold material, for duh-simple try lost foam. Get some blue insulation board type foam, carve your bolster/guard/brass knife blank and attach a sprue to it with a bit of hot melt glue. Bury this in dry sand and pour the metal in the sprue. The metal vaporizes and displaces the foam, and voila, a cast piece. Easy peasy. Just be careful, before you know it you will have another hobby. I'm coming at this from the other way, I have been metalcasting and am trying to get started in blacksmithing, I think they will compliment each other nicely.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Consider all fumes while casting as hazardous. Some more so than others. There are numerous books, and items on the web for home casters. Read up before undertaking this endeavor, as some information may be outdated, or contradictory. I have one book where the guy mentions breathing a cupolas worth of zinc fumes over the years with no ill effects. Personal safety equipment is cheap compared to hospital stays, and treatment, or a funeral. The foundry that I worked in had a fume hood right next to the crucible, and you could see the fumes getting pulled off. Be safe, and have fun.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I see the problem being that a lot of us *know* how to work dangerous materials safely; but the people we are talking to may not. I never want to run up against someone saying "but you said it could be used" and having totally ignored the safety comments they are now working on leaving a widow and small kids and massive medical bills behind them.

So I will not advocate using BeCu, what if the next guy to own the piece decides to re-grind it? Or their grandson? I will always warn about zinc fumes; besides Paw Paw I had a 19 year old student I warned about zinc and by the next year he had put himself in the hospital with metal fume fever---with no insurance BTW.

I won't stop other folks from playing with fire; but I'd like them to do it as safely as possible!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I agree with Thomas. I came to blacksmithing through metal casting like you,why waste all the heat? There are safer brass/bronze alloys out there than the ones containing Beryllium. My question is why not advocate their use rather than something that has a greater potential for harm like a Beryllium/Copper alloy? Yes it can be used but why take an uncalled for risk when it can be avoided. If you want to use it that is up to you but I don't think that you should advocate others to follow suit.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Darton, for run of the mill got-it-at-a-yard-sale-from-India brass (which is pretty much what I use) the major concern will be zinc, if you badly overheat it. Large amounts of white smoke will be produced and if inhaled can (if you are silly enough to stand in the plume and continuously breathe it) can cause a condition known as "zinc-fume fever", the symptoms are similar to a mild case of the flu, fever, chills, and just a general crappy feeling. This is temporary, and goes away in a day or so. If you get it,******************. I can't speak from personal experience, I have never had it, and I have had the lovely column of dense white smoke erupting from my furnace on more than a few occasions. Keeping an eye on things and a cover flux of either charcoal or borax will help. If you are really worried, get some non-zinc bearing silicon bronze, such as Everdure or a similar alloy. I would still only do this with a lot of ventilation, I concur with the others that common sense and a few simple safety precautions, and a healthy respect for really hot stuff will serve you well.
As far as BeCu, I'm not even sure where you could get it, I've seen the conversation come up a few times as well and I don't want to mess with it. Kind of why I use yellow decorative brass, looks good, casts reasonably well, and more or less known hazards.

Edited by mod07
Dangeroujs Myth removed
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Milk is a myth, it will help some people with some symptoms, but it doesn't treat the problem. If you suspect that you have metal fume fever you go to the hospital and tell them that you have been exposed to large amounts of metal fumes including the various materials you have been heating.

Shop Safety III : A Case Study : Zinc Metal Fume Fever - anvilfire iForge Demo
http://www.iforgeiron.com/forum/f12/ppw-fume-fever-112/
http://www.iforgeiron.com/forum/f35/zinc-1719/

Be safe. Last thing that needs to happen is someone getting themselves dead.

Phil

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Pk, the milk was from what I had read on different sites, if I gave out bad info I apologise, I read through the links that you put up and it more or less concurs with the rest that I knew about it. Long and the short of it is like anything else related to hot metal, know your materials and the hazards associated with them, use proper techniques and equipment, and pay attention to what you are doing. Clean the surfaces before welding, don't overheat the melt, more than adequate ventilation, don't rub your eyes after picking habanero peppers, etc. etc.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 9 years later...

Hi all. On the topic of brass - I am new to knife making - I thought aged brass looks cool so I bought a blank slab to have a crack at making a knife out of. I wasn’t going to attempt heat treating at this stage just shaping it as a bit of a fun project (I only have a few basic tools at home). Is the summary that I shouldn’t bother? And it’s hazardous to grind? 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Which of the several hundred alloys of brass did you buy? Does it contain any toxic materials in it?

What gives you the idea that you can harden brass with heat treatment?  Many brass alloys you heat to a dull red and quench in water to SOFTEN it?

What do you want to use the blade for?

Copper/Tin Bronze was once used as a common blade material; it even has around the same hardness as mild wrought iron if handled right; but once they learned to harden steel it dropped out of favour quickly as steel will get very much harder than bronze will.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The listing says - “Brass Flat Bar - Grade C380 / C385 at 300mm long” - it doesn’t say anything about the materials within the alloy. Maybe i’d Have to contact the manufacturer. The purpose is really just for practice, to be ornamental and not necessarily functional as I’m just learning / teaching myself. I suppose purchasing an unsuitable material can just go down as a lesson learned. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

a simple search turned up this at online metals:

C385 BRASS/ARCHITECTURAL BRONZE CHEMICAL AND MECHANICAL PROPERTIES

Melting Point 1610° F – 877° C
Chemistry
Copper (Cu) – 55-59%
Iron (Fe) – 0.35%
Lead (Pb) – 2.5-3.5%
Remainder – Zinc (Zn)
Soldering – Excellent
Brazing – Good
Welding – Not recommended

Lead helps the machinability properties of Brass, (see C360 Free Machining Brass for example); but is not generally a good element for things you will handle a lot and be careful of dust from grinding or buffing.

Why not practice on the metal you hope to work with in the future?  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...