Jump to content
I Forge Iron

Making wrought iron damascus or pattern welded blade


Fe-Wood

Recommended Posts

I have a bunch of single refined wrought iron and am thinking about making a couple kitchen knives. I'm not sure what steel will be good to use for the "high carbon" part of the billet. I have forged a few billets out of steel that someone else put together and don't remember what they used. 

 

I'm looking for ideas on what would be a good steel to use with the wrought iron and why. I'm would also like input on heat treating the finished blades.

 

Thanks!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just remember, wrought iron has little to no carbon content so what ever high carbon steel you choose to use that carbon will want to migrate into the  wrought.  I would use 1095 minimum.  I'm curious, maybe those who have done it before can answer, If using a high carbon chromium steel like 52100 would mitigate the migration since the chromium is a stronge bonding agent with iron and carbon and the chromium won't migrate.  Hmm.  Just a random thought.  Just remember whatever you decide to use work it fast.  The longer it stays at forging temps the greater carbon loss you'll have.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

the chrome and its carbides that have formed should stay, but the free carbon will migrate. I posted a report from electron microscope a few years ago, its happens much faster than any of us used to think too.

Thanks steve, that's kind of what I would have predicted.  That's the beautiful thing about steel, it is predicable.  I'll have to see if I can find that post.

As far as your hardening/temper it is almost impossible to predict as forging time and what you start with will greatly affect the end product.  It could harden in oil if you have worked it reall fast (read in BIG power hammer) or it might not even harden in water (hand forged/folded many times).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hmmm. Great input jm. I was thinking of using the same thickness for the layers of the billet. Would thicker layers of high carbon steel work to my advantage? Also, I'll be using a coal forge. In terms of speed, how many heats are we talking about for forming the billet and forming the blade?

 

Steve- thanks for the link

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hmmm. Great input jm. I was thinking of using the same thickness for the layers of the billet. Would thicker layers of high carbon steel work to my advantage? Also, I'll be using a coal forge. In terms of speed, how many heats are we talking about for forming the billet and forming the blade?

 

Steve- thanks for the link

It all comes down to layer count.  According to Wayne Goddard carbon atoms migrate the width of a hair an hour.  Not much but if your layers are less than that total migration can take place in less than 30 mins.  My personal rule of thumb for doing high/low Damascus is to start with thin layers and fold no more than 2 times.  Sometimes you can slip a peice of high carbon in the center on the final fold that will form the edge.  That will give you a higher carbon content for the cutting edge. 

Personally I would suggest using an all high carbon billet.  I use L-6/1095 as it has a bold pattern and carbon migration isn't a problem since it's all high carbon.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  Sometimes you can slip a peice of high carbon in the center on the final fold that will form the edge.  That will give you a higher carbon content for the cutting edge. 

Personally I would suggest using an all high carbon billet.  I use L-6/1095 as it has a bold pattern and carbon migration isn't a problem since it's all high carbon.

 

I Like the idea of using a piece of high carbon for the cutting edge. Thanks for the input on materials and carbon migration. This will be my first blade so keeping it simple will be a good thing.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Who is a good supplier for small amounts of L-6 and 1095? Any idea of the billet size (how many pieces, thickness , width, length) I would need in order to make a classic chefs knife with about an 8" blade with the full tang between the scales?

 

Thanks!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You might want to try a san-mai type construction... basically just a 3 layer weld.

 

This one is a big old file between 2 layers of wrought wagon wheel rim.

 

The pattern you see is the teeth of the file coming through the grind.

 

kith2.jpg

 

If I was using virgin steel for the edge layer, I'd probably go for 1084

 

Aldo Bruno (New Jersey Steel Baron) can hook you up on the steel.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Steve, that link doesn't take me to the article, just the ASM Home page. I did a carbon migration search and came up empty. 

 

I know, that is why I said I need to re locate the University links, they have made changes  that was what I referred to,  for some odd reason they made a change to their website in the past 4 years, without telling us, How rude of them...  :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If you have to ask such questions it usually means you don't have a lot of experience doing things that way and getting a good weld without overheating the highC or underheating the WI for a piece as large as to make a good chef's knife will probably take a trial or two to get down cold (so to speak) so bet on needing several times more to make sure you end up with enough---horrible to get things just right only to find out you have to start over again as you ran out of alloy XYZ and it take weeks to get more due to the zombie apocalypse, or a hurricane, or an earthquake, etc...

 

My favorite for juicing up billets is old black diamond files when they were 1.2%c  I used to pick them up at the fleamarket whenever they turned up cheap---puzzled a lot of dealers that I would buy all they had under my price point but wouldn't buy *any* above it.  They thought that if I wanted them so much I'd pay more---as I had 20 pounds of them already at home I wasn't hurting to get more...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

So Thomas, thanks for telling me how much I don't know and for pointing out the obvious. This is exactly why I'm asking the questions and hoping for real answers. Like "expect to loose about 30% of the steel to scale and finish"... I'm using 30% as an example here. With all the outstanding knife makers on this forum I would think this a fairly straight forward question. I'm happy you have a pile of juicy files piled away Thomas you should be proud!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

relax Fewood, things are so easy to misunderstand from a forum with cold text, I have offended so many people where I did not have that intent,  This happens due to assumptions from the reader gettting none of my inflections or missing my scarcasum, or even like Thomas just said: stating obvious to be clear for the many readers that dont read the entire threadd, only a few posts, then get upset from out of context things said.

 

 

Also I think you should plan closer to 50% losses just starting out pattern welding as a good start.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

A lot depends on which pattern you make and if you plan to grind or forge to shape.

 

For a first try I would strongly remember the old sheffield proverb "If a good blade you would win, you should forge thick and grind thin"

 

As for exactly how much---take the knife you are trying to replicate and get several times as much steel as it weighs now  and even then don't be surprised if your chef's knife ends up a boning knife.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thank you both. That was an answer I can work with. 50% or more for loss is a number I can start with. I just get tired of people putting up posts to pretty specific questions without including real pertinent information. I've been smithing long enough to know almost any question can be answered with; "it depends on..."No offense taken or intended...

 

I will be forge welding the leaves of the billet together then doing a knick/fold forge weld 2 maybe 3 times. As this blade is a learning piece, I'm going to forge to finish or close anyway.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...