I can identify with the situation the OP is describing. As a beginner myself it can be a bit daunting to know what to do first. Luckily, I have access to some basic tools and very well set up Forge via a local artist blacksmith shop that is set up as a bit of a community blacksmithing center (rent a forge). My plan, not saying this is the ONLY way to go, is to start by making only the tools I need to get the job done. I will have a couple of hammers (one bought, one found) and that's about it. My current plan is to start making some bottle openers (with any luck, I might be able to post a photo of one in a few weeks :-)). For that I will need to punch/slit a hole. So first tool I'll need will be a punch and/or a slitting punch. I'll also need a bob punch for the little tab. I can probably borrow some tongs for a while, but a basic pair of tongs will also be on the list. These punches will then be the first things (other than some random stuff (Tapers, S hooks, twists, etc) I did in the beginners course offered by the blacksmithing center). These tools will likely not be the finest examples of their type and may not work as well as ones made by experienced smiths. But the point of making them is to start to get experience. Try making tools, see if they work and learn from the mistakes I'll almost certainly make. While I would love a hot cut hardie of my own, that's a fair way down the path at the moment. My advise would be to have a go at it, but start with modest and simple tools. Of course, I'm not exactly speaking from experience though, rather more from the shared and palpable anticipation of experience I'm yet to gain. The sage advice of others with experience is definitely worth taking. Cheers, Gumbatron