I would say more the concept. I am trying to get a sense of what realistic possibilities there are and then go from there.
So for example whether the two magnets are square or round in cross section is not critical. 8.67 " is a maximum outside diameter. Less than that is OK.
If someone comes up with a possibility, we can take measurements and see how that would work, but there is flexibility.
There is also the goal, aside from an actual pair of magnets, of getting a better sense of how an 1837 blacksmith might have gone about such, both technique and materials. An area you fellows might well have a sense of. And perhaps be interested in.
Thomas Davenport was a remarkable person, blacksmith and scientist, and well worth learning about.