Manothewoods, Welding clean metal is easier but is not essential if you are just knocking up a non structural forge or framework. However in saying, traces of slag deposits from previous welds can be a curse if trying to fill holes etc. it acts like a volcano and keeps spewing out leaving the same hole your trying to fix. Use a scribe to remove the deposit and your well on your way. but less time cleaning up the steel initially unless its loose crusty rust which will result in crappy and weak welds.