This topic has gone down the garden path and round Will's mother's and I have lost the plot. I thought this started off about training and safety. Now as everyone else is interested in qualifications, as a smith I have none, grew up on a farm with a smiths shed at the bottom of the garden and an old welder in the barn, did what was need to keep things going. However I spent 25 years in the US military, have prefix of Master on several qualifications, enough paper to cover a large den wall. Not one of those ceritficates ment much to the other guys I worked with, what I produced and my reputation did tho. That experiance has taught me that BOTH formal training and HANDS ON with a more experianced and skilled person is need to produce high quality work in a short time. If you go just the school route, the 'Time served' element is missed. and for those of us that are self taught then we spend too much time learning by mistakes and learning bad habits.
I will not take sides here, I have seen some dangerous suggestions put forth (not so much on this web site, Glenn and others jump in on them, but youtube is scary sometimes). I have also learned a lot of good techniques. I would like to work with a smith occationaly to see how others do various tasks.
As for the certificates: Red I live in England and the goverment requirements for paperwork is a**inine and over the top and it still does not stop the cowboy builders. Trying to fix shoddy workmanship through regulation is an impossibility.
As I read through the replies I keep seeing the same theame: There are a lot of smiths out there that would like to' if not serve a full apprenticeship at least get the oppertunity to work with an experianced smith to learn more about the craft. Can you experienced smiths drop the bickering and possibly offer up to those of us that could use it.
I have to classifiy myself as a self taught/learner smith. This is due to not finding a smith or school close enough and willing to show me smithing. I have to keep the day job to pay the mortgage and HMIR. Smithing for me is an will be a hobby for a long time. I will not be competing with you proffesionals, so my stake in this is about the training. Rather than all the sniping, how about working up some sort of training help for wantaby smiths.
Red, you commented on the lack of safety. Could you do a thread on shop safety? I know there is some info on another site, but I don't remember any on the oxy/gas welding. and everyone could use safety refresher from time to time.
Red, Basher, Wayne, or anyother UK based smiths; you guys know anyone around the Cambridgeshire/Norfolk area that would share info? Wayne, I met you at Pensthorpe a coulple of years ago, I am working on a travel forge based off yours, thanks for the start on the research.
Glenn, sorry about the ramble