I am new to this forum... but not to bladesmithing/blacksmithing, and I just want to say:
Anyone asking questions (on or about anything) needs to be ready to hear an answer they won't like.
A long time ago I was an Apprentice at AngelSword...
I learned a lot about bladesmithing... but learned more about humility.
If anyone finds these suggestions harsh, meanspirted, disheartening or discouraging then I only have one thing to say...
Check your ego.
Iceforge... spend the time to learn how to do it right and well. I teach how to make blades in my spare time, my kids spend most, like 3/4ths the time on just developing there hammer skills, and they have been at it for 9months.
Also, you can read and watch youtube all you want but it all goes out the door once you get to the anvil.
So... practice on mild steel. Even if your goal is to make a blade you will only use once. Do it right or leave it to the people who will.
Even after 17 years of smithin' I get my xxxx kicked by the steel from time to time. That is when I check my ego...
Many who have responed to this topic have spent more time making blades then any beginner has spent thinking about making blades.
Practice does not make Perfect. Perfect Practice makes Perfect.
Take heed, and realize... the only way any of us has been able to stay at this art is by being wise enough to listen but tenacious enough not to dispare.
Sorry to bloviate,
Gabriel