Man I'll have to try all that you guys recommended. The viniger solution sounds interesting. I wouldn't have thought about that.
My next question is, for the actual striking surface will that need to be completely smooth and flat? There are some bumps, divets, etc. on all sides. Should I smooth, out the face or should I just beat around with it the way it is. If I need to do this how best should it be done. Since it is more than just surface rust would the viniger solution still work?
No doubt after I get this block laid out the way I want it I'll find an honest to goodness anvil. But like I said earlier I've been learning a ton just working with junk, and this is something I've never put much worth in, in the past. But every little bit helps from what people have told me.
The festival is located in Springs Pennsylvania. The site for the festival and organization is Springs Historical Society and if I remember correctly there is a smith or two present with their wares. One I believe is a knife smith. As far as market items, with me not knowing what to look for before, everything seemed like rusted junk tools and devices that I had no idea what their purpose was. But it's a fun festival and if you go there, just go down to the food stand at the bottom of the hill and get yourself a half dozen of their home made doughnuts and then some apple cider from another vendor. Dress in layers cuz I've never been there when the weather was 100% pleasant all day. I'll stop now because I'm starting to get a little homesick ;-).
Take care and I hope to see you there.
-Dan
P.S. As with everything it's "feast or famine". This is another festival right up the road from us that has a huge flea market which I remember had smithing tools Burlington United Methodist Family Services, Inc. . But the springs festival is a family tradition.