yo, thanks for posting this. i'm also a noobie blade smith, i made some blacksmith's knives based on the designs made my mr lively (see livelyknives.com), and it made me feel pretty good that i can shape a piece of metal to resemble a master piece so closely. lol
i've only recently started working with steel, made three pieces so far. (before i made things from aluminum, which was a lot easier to work with, at least most of the times) my first steel piece was a 'stolen' design, and i am pretty satisfied with how much it resembles the original work. i think for a beginner like me, it's better to try duplicating some one else's work, 'cause it give you no excuse to "change the plan". some times, when i try to work an original idea i would just wonder away and make something completely different because i'm not yet skilled enough to make what i want or i just messed up and decided to keep going. when i try duplicating someone else's work, i always sit down and plan out the whole thing, and there's no "ooops, oh well...", and what comes out in the end always satisfies me, and 'cause the finished work is already made for me, i would know exactly what i want. so ya... i think that's a great way for me to get the practice. lol ;]