While I am relatively new to blacksmithing, I would like to think I have my feet under me as far as basic skills go. However, I don't know of any experienced smiths in my area, so I have to turn to books and this wonderful forum.
In The Blacksmith's Craft: A Primer of Tools & Methods by Charles McRaven, he states that after running the colors in a forge (heat treating) you should not quench your tool/project. Apparently, quenching the tool could harden the tool again.
My latest project was a punch drawn out from a piece of coil spring (5160-ish), so I know there's enough carbon to allow hardening. After completely hardening (heat to red, then quench) I stuck the blunt end in the forge, and slowly ran the colors until the business end was a light straw. Heeding Mr. McRaven's advise, I allowed the punch to air-cool, and by the time it had cooled, the tip was a honey-bronze.
My question is; can I somehow cool my workpiece more quickly without jeopardizing the heat treatment process?