Jump to content
I Forge Iron

Recommended Posts

I'm going to start with the price point. On the website it was listed at $329 Canadian but with exchange rate I got it for $286 USD including tax. Shipping to my address in Michigan would have been $132 not sure if that's Canadian or USD. I was passing through and happened to be going by one so I didn't have to pay shipping.

So I decided to buy the princess auto 110# anvil the other day for the sole purpose of doing a review on it. I have other anvils that are good quality so I didn't really need this one. 

Lets start with the quality of the finish. The horn is very rough and you can see some grind lines through the paint. The very tip of the horn has a defect. And the it is nor conical like the picture suggests.

The face of the anvil has 2 very small inclusions or pits and it appears that someone took a grinder with a flap disk to it. Not sure why but there is no start and stop marks from the grinder so whoever was running the grinder knows what they are doing. 

The paint itself seems very cheap and flakes away fairly easy after it has started to. 

The transition from theface to the horn could have been done a lot better. There is a drop from the face to the horn where it would be nice to have it flush. The way it is now will leave marks in the workpiece when drifting holes.

Speaking of holes...let's talk about them. They are very dirty. Not sure how rough they are but they are definitely dirty. We will see when I get a chance to blow then out and clean them up.

All of these things are me picking it apart. Now its time to talk about the good. 

The rebound is EXCELLENT!!! 90% or more with a 7/8" ball bearing at 10 inches.

The size of the working surface is impressive as is how smooth the face is. It has VERY sharp edges.  

I have video of the rebound test and pictures that I am going to update this with but I had a couple things come up and had to take off but when I get home I will post them. 

Over all I really like this little guy. But the test of time will be the ultimate test and I will update this as time passes and damage is afflicted.

Horn defect

20180417_125923.thumb.jpg.805c67d7667301a42fa4da53f08bfd28.jpg.f37bb5454a1ca480e61b406098c35c67.jpg

Paint chipping and grind lines in horn20180417_125749.thumb.jpg.1188631a90ba8937189a48985ae2b224.jpg.e84aa4767574672da2f47208be68678a.jpg

Grinder marks on face20180417_125718.thumb.jpg.9f646b29343bc8c78e45492b170cc04e.jpg.995377866adc6df7722b4a280c1c6a41.jpg

2 small pits in face

 20180417_130017.thumb.jpg.1d8597a32638dc3527d2b201b766d9dc.jpg.4c56c8bf8a45e9f9a2801ec231a4274b.jpg20180417_125952.thumb.jpg.05f08916de7972d692d016c2a75eacab.jpg.d57d4f0bc2e38db28d9823e370eed734.jpg

Rough casting on horn and raised transition from face to horn where pritchel is.

20180417_125832.thumb.jpg.9804a2a7f949cc9e49e73648c7e87212.jpg.05399c7b9b2d754e3fc2fc8c63c59f3e.jpg

Hardy hole and pritchel hole.20180417_130038.thumb.jpg.3a07218d095b6374c9b53ee9893fa7da.jpg.610525b4fff421620fa7d7721d532730.jpg20180417_130047.thumb.jpg.34cbd482d782a8d2512a92b21d008583.jpg.2f9303f142a967867c7018083cd36bdf.jpg

Im uploading a video to YouTube of the rebound test and will post it soon.

Link to post
Share on other sites

$50 cheaper would have been nice but it is still the cheapest anvil in its weight category. I believe the next cheapest would be the NC Calvary which from what i have hear is barely out of the ASO category. So for $160 cheaper than the NC this cant be that much worse even after spending the time cleaning it up. And for the same price as the NC 70lb anvil you get 30lbs more. The one thing i wish is that the shipping was a little cheaper.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Here is a video comparing the princess auto anvil rebound next to the rebound on my vulcan 100#er. The vulcan has 80% rebound and the princess auto anvil has 90% rebound. You can also hear the distinct difference in sound.

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Rebound test still shot on both anvils.

Vulcan:

IMG_20180503_101416.thumb.jpg.5290887bab14e9ecb6161ad9c1ef1ab8.jpg

Princess auto:IMG_20180503_101316.thumb.jpg.d831203bdaaa8638f92749f8f10ac1dc.jpg

Size reference next to my vulcan #10

IMG_20180503_101641.thumb.jpg.6230dc4fb848fd937b66a4ebc94ff2c2.jpgIMG_20180503_101658.thumb.jpg.e2175826be007e1fc8f4a9231c749fb1.jpg

I began cleaning up the horn. I am using a file because i dont ever use power tools on an anvil. Im going to add that a file cuts steel on the horn ok but skates a file on the face.

20180503_191828.thumb.jpg.b7367ca377c15a9c53d5ed7dd16004b9.jpg20180503_192018.thumb.jpg.c3380a4f70bfa6a4d71751f0e1769a37.jpg20180503_191756.thumb.jpg.dab9a868b486f9e78d720306ae809dc5.jpg

IMG_20180503_101641.jpg

Link to post
Share on other sites

HUSTON WE HAVE A PROBLEM!!!

20180510_113219.thumb.jpg.4d0525b8b444c0f3118e4f2a358f3090.jpg

I figured out why they took a grinder to the face! I think this circle spot is filler rod and they ground it flush. The rebound drops right off to nothing over this spot. Here is a perfect example of poor quality control with these anvils. I mean come on. One thing i have to say is all the way around the spot has excelent rebound and then you drop a bearing over this spot and its dead.

It was hard to get the camera to focus. Im going to get a better pictures and a video of the rebound over the spot.

One thing that gets me is it has this spot but rings like a bell. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

20180510_120611.jpg now i understand why people go to school for photography.

Is the sprue the excess from casting that gets cut off?

The spot is about 1 1/4 inches. 

1525968924183-2135435333.jpg

I think these are cast on there side.

1525969060387-936304997.jpg

Link to post
Share on other sites

sprue:    spro͞o/,  noun, 1: a channel through which metal or plastic is poured into a mold. 2: a piece of metal or plastic that has solidified in a sprue, especially one joining a number of small molded plastic items.

Note that castings can have multiple sprues and vents too. (we will not discuss gates!)

Link to post
Share on other sites

I know about vents but the last picture of the side of the anvil i showed i belive is where the sprue was cut off. 

And it seems like this would be an odd place for a vent.

Im working on uploading a video to YouTube of the rebound over the spot 

Link to post
Share on other sites

 

I was wondering the same thing. But the spot is there and it really didnt start showing until i started working steel on it. 

On 4/17/2018 at 4:44 PM, JlBlohm said:

small pits in face

 20180417_130017.thumb.jpg.1d8597a32638dc3527d2b201b766d9dc.jpg.4c56c8bf8a45e9f9a2801ec231a4274b.jpg

This was the original photo of the spot on the edge of the defect and the circle cant be seen. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

well, at that price it would be a decent anvil in spite of the flaws. and it has two horns, which is a plus, it's an Italian pattern anvil, as seen by a chinese manufacturer. that soft spot is easily avoidable if that bothers someone, plenty of working surface left. just put some radius on the edges and bolt it down firmly on some kind of base

Link to post
Share on other sites

As small as the spot is it doesn't hurt this thing a bit. I am debating on selling this anvil and upgrading to the Holland alloys anvil and start a review about that one. The princess auto anvil review will continue. The next time im in the Detroit area im going to jump to Canada and grab another one. 

Should I sell it? I will be going down in size but a huge jump in quality!

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...