The ball of glam has come up from the pot and I piled on a large mound of coal to insulate and hopefully expand the heat.
I think my fatal flaw was my fire pot design and the way I supplied it air. I will probably get more metal and weld up a larger firepot to forge in. Is there a way to make a large firepot into a sideblast of sorts? My orginal design had my air funneling from the side of the fire and that really seemed to create a good fire. (Also trying to get away from my air supply hole getting clogged by dust, small coal or a clinker.)
By the way, the idea behind a solid fuel forge finally dawned on me. I think the only reason my orginal design worked was because it was in a deepish bowl shape, giving me a crude fire pot. Now it seems really simple to make a forge with the idea of a "hole in the ground with a air supply"
P.S. you guys are awesome. I'm taking so much info in, makes all my previous theories crumble