Glenn, good point. Everquest 2 is a good example of this. I was taken by rpgs for a while and although my barbarian berserker enjoyed forging weapons and armor made of such things as 'blackened iron', I think he spent most of his time making household items. I would run around and gather components for hours then run back to my guild and forge these components into more components and so on and so fourth until finally I had made an arrowhead, candle holder or 'super duper sword of death' .. I can remember camping (means leaving the game) and telling my group that I had to go meet my brother at the forge, which led to a whole lot of oohhhs and ahhhhhs along with some intelligent conversation about the how, where and why of my love of smithing. I have since put away the EQ2 hat as I began to feel that it was just not the best use of what little time it feels like I have, but I am still a nerd at heart and will always think Dwarven Smiths (Sindri or Brok anyone??) are cool. Anyway one thing I can say is that nothing compares to the actual feel of the hammer in hand, but without my imagination, life would not be near as fun. Swords or candle holders it does not matter to me and someday maybe I will be able to 'know it all' . At least I will try my darndest,.. and yes, I am often asked if I shoe horses or if I can make a sword, to which I usually reply not yet but maybe one day.
So what does it matter if a someone asks? How else would they learn??