Thanks to everyone for the suggestions. Sorry I wasn't able to get back on here for a few weeks, got busy on a number of other things and didn't have the time.
I will post some shots of the anvil as soon as I get the chance. Right now I have it sitting on a stump that I compensated for by using a ball peen hammer to make an indent for the offset foot. I think when I get a chance, I will heat it up and see if I can carefully coax it back into plain with the other 3 feet. (Correct, this is wrought iron)
As I stated before, I'm not a blacksmith or a farrier, but just an all round got stuff to fix guy. I don't know how anyone lives without a good anvil. I use this thing constantly.
- Mark