Tfs smithy special reviews.
Posted 24 July 2013 - 08:33 AM
Posted 24 July 2013 - 09:19 AM
I used the TFS double horn 100 lb anvil for a few months at a shop I worked in. It seemed like a fine anvil.
I do not like the hardy hole so close to the round horn on the larger TFS double horn. Some of your hardy tools can hang out over the horn and be unsupported. I plan to buy a Refflinghaus #57 220lb. There hardy hole is set farther into the face
Posted 24 July 2013 - 09:37 AM
TFS anvils are made from ductile iron not steel. If I was going to spend $1500 on a 300 pound anvil I think I would just save up a little extra and get a something made from tool steel in roughly the same weight range. To me the investment is to large not to get the steel anvil. There are several and tool steel anvils in the 250 – 275 range that are in the same price range or only slightly higher. I would look at Nimba, Fontanini, Rhino, and Peddinghaus.
That being said I worked on a JMH Competitor, also ductile iron, for a week and thought it was a very good anvil. The owner of the anvil works on it full time and he had only positive things to say about it.
Posted 24 July 2013 - 02:14 PM
Posted 24 July 2013 - 02:52 PM
I bought a 275 Peddinghaus anvil from Blacksmith depot a few years ago. I think the shipping was closer to $100 than $400 or $500. They shipped it to a freight terminal in my town and I went and picked it up as that was the cheapest shipping option. I'm sure it's more now but $400 seems like a lot. Have you gotten a freight quote from anyone yet?
One more thing you might check is Home Depot is a supplier for Ridgid tools and Ridgid owns Peddinghaus. Before I ordered my anvil from Blacksmiths Depot I checked with customer service at HD and they could order one for me and have it delivered to the store without a shipping charge. At the time it was a little more expensive even without shipping so I ordered from Blacksmith Depot. However I see Blacksmith Depot's price have gone up several hundred dollars since I ordered mine. It might be worth checking with Home Depot to see what they can get one for.
I do hope someone here has a TFS they can give a review of. I am in that area at least once a year and have been considering getting one of the smaller ones for my son.
Posted 24 July 2013 - 03:42 PM
Posted 24 July 2013 - 04:56 PM
Who were the ones you got quotes from? I wonder if Blacksmith Deport, Pieh, or Centar have better arrangements with the shipping companies?
How does the local price compare to what TFS lists it for on there site?
Posted 24 July 2013 - 06:15 PM
The 80-55-06 ductile iron grade has a ferritic/pearlitic matrix. The mechanical properties of 80-55-06 will be similar to medium carbon steels that contain up to 0.50% carbon including 1040, 1045, 1141, and 1144.
All grades of ductile iron bar stock respond very well to conventional heat-treating methods.
All I need is a good response from someone that's actually owned or used one extensively. I emailed a guy on a different forge that talked about him buying a 300lber, but he didn't say how it was. So I'll let you guys know what he says if he even responds.
Posted 25 July 2013 - 01:11 AM
I bought a 300# Fisher anvil from a lady in Massachusetts and had it shipped to my door in SC for $200. Like you, I had a lot of quotes from shipping companies that were astronomical, but I waited. U-ship.com has a lot of small carriers that bid, and one of them hit me the cheapest quote. It was beautiful.
All told, I got the anvil into the ship for less than $3/lb, and that's a great price.
If you're not in a hurry, use searchtempest.com to find anvils that are relatively local to you. Granted, OK is a large area to cover, but it's certainly worth it if you save $500 on the cost of the anvil.
Posted 25 July 2013 - 07:44 AM
Posted 25 July 2013 - 09:00 AM
You might shoot primtechsmith a PM. I know he uses a JMH Competitor and is pretty pleased with it. It’s not a TFS but it is made from ductile iron. See post http://www.iforgeiro...y-good/?p=27713
I think if you checked with a manufacturer or one of the blacksmith supply companies that already has a relationship with a shipping company the rates will be much less than what you are getting quoted.
I’m not trying to discourage you from getting a TFS if that is what suits your needs the best. I also agree it would be awesome to have a 400lb double horn anvil sitting in my shop. I just wanted to make sure you thought about the other options in the price range and I don’t think they can be fairly evaluated at the shipping rates you were quoted.
What is the price of the TFS from your local guy? TFS lists the 400lb Smithy Special at $1694 and the 300lb at $1449. If your guy is more than that there may be a hidden shipping charge so to speak.
Good luck with your purchase no matter what you choose. If you do get the TFS please post a review on it as I would like to know how they perform.
Posted 25 July 2013 - 09:39 AM
Watch out for some of those "cheap" shipping companies. I've had one of them unband & depalletize items on me resulting in damage & uloading problems. They basically told me tough luck when I called them up about it.
Posted 25 July 2013 - 10:37 AM
Thank you so much for the link to primetechsnith I will shoot him a pm and see what he has to say about the JMH. If Home Depot gives free shipping and a slightly lower price than what kayne and son are offering ill jump on that Peddinghaus.
Pound for pound and convenience. It's definitely looking like I'll be getting a TFS if primetechsmith has nothing but good things to say about the other ductile iron anvil. Or unless someone shows up saying to steer clear of it. I just don't see a huge company like TFS putting out a bad product when it's centered around smithing? That's their business after all.
Posted 31 July 2013 - 08:38 AM
In addition to brand, it's a good idea to look at an anvil's features. Does it have a step? Location and size of the hardy hole? Location and size of the pritchel hole? Width of the face? Shape of the heel? Shape of the horn? I personally advocate a step, a 1" hardy hole toward the heel, an offset pritchel hole, a wide face, conical horn and tapered heel. Unless you're doing really heavy work, I wouldn't recommend an anvil heavier than 300 lb -- it's just too difficult to move around the shop. Hardness and composition of the steel is very important: Below about 52 Rockwell it dents too easily. Above about 58 Rockwell the edges are likely to chip. High chrome content helps make it tougher.
Posted 31 July 2013 - 09:14 AM
1 user(s) are reading this topic
0 members, 1 guests, 0 anonymous users